
Thule Approach 2 Medium
A roomy soft shell that opens in minutes, locks to your rack, and has a 2.4-inch foam mattress. Buy it unless you need a hard shell.
+−Read the full write-upHide the full write-up
Why I picked it
Four poles hold the walls out, so you can sit up without the roof on your head, and skylights and big windows keep it bright. The dual-layer foam mattress is 2.4 inches thick with a quilted cover, twice as thick as the Sirius 1's.
Mounting is where it pulls ahead. The brackets lock to the rack and come with a tool that stops you from overtightening, and Thule says they go on in half the usual time. You'll still want a second person to lift 128 pounds onto the roof, but taking it off for the winter stops being a project.
Who it is for
Two adults, or two adults and a small child, who camp often and want a tent that stays comfortable through a long trip. For a family, the Approach 2 Large sleeps three to four for about $3,600.
Skip it if
You move camp every morning in the rain. The cover comes off completely each time, and there's nowhere to stow it at camp.
What reviewers found
Reviewers keep naming the Approach the best soft shell they've used. In one long review of the Medium, setup came down to under a minute with the ladder as a lever, and the rainfly was close to impenetrable. Another review found that rainfly a reach to secure. The small daily annoyance is lining up the cover's zipper ends.
Flaws but not dealbreakers
- About $3,000, and the awning is extra.
- The rainfly is a reach to secure.
- The cover comes off fully every time.




