
Smartwool Classic Thermal Merino Crew
All merino at 250 grams per square meter, warm enough for a winter day and still breathable on the climb. About $125, with matching bottoms and a women's cut.
+−Read the full write-upHide the full write-up
Why I picked it
The fabric is 250 grams per square meter of merino, the midweight that works from a frosty October morning to a January day below freezing. Wool keeps you warm even damp, it breathes when you push uphill, and it doesn't stink after a weekend. The seams are flat, so nothing rubs under pack straps, and the top weighs about 10 ounces in a men's medium.
It's cut slim, so it sits close to your skin, where a base layer does its job. Matching bottoms turn it into a set of long underwear, and the women's version is sold in the same fabric.
Who it is for
Day hikers and backpackers who go out from late fall to early spring, and anyone who wants one warm wool layer for hiking, camp and skiing.
What owners report
Warmth is what owners mention most. A snowboarder wore his every day for five days in Vail, in weather from 5°F to 55°F, and says it never started to smell. The unhappy review comes from a man who wore it on a brisk five-mile walk at 30 to 40°F, under a sweater and a jacket: it came home soaked with sweat. He now saves it for slower days.
Durability is where buyers part ways. A man who has bought about thirty of them over the years says some last a long time and some fray at the collar sooner than expected, and another owner wears through the elbows. On size, the sleeves run a little long and the fabric loosens after the first wear: a buyer at 6'2" found the large tight at first, then just right.
Flaws but not dealbreakers
- Merino wears faster than polyester, especially where pack straps rub.
- Too warm for a steep climb in mild weather. Take the All-Season for that.
- About $125 for the top alone, and the bottoms cost about the same again.
Fit and sizing
Slim fit in your usual size. It loosens a little after the first wear.




